The perils and pleasures of binge reading

I think I’m a bit of a completist on the quiet. Over the past few years I’ve had seasonal obsessions with Arnold Bennett, Rosamond Lehmann, Anne Tyler, Carol Shields, H.G. Wells, Philip Roth, Patrick Hamilton, James Ellroy, Iain M. Banks and George Pelecanos. Looking back at my diary, I see that 2003 was my Dickens year, 2005 was Hardy and 2006 was Zola.  (Every year is a Trollope year.) The summer of 2013 was the entire Game of Thrones series.


Right now, I can feel a Barbara Pym phase coming on. It started with Some Tame Gazelle at Christmas. Then one of my oldest friends gave me Excellent Women for my birthday, I’ve just polished off Jane and Prudence, and now I’m staring at a pile of Pyms I’ve picked up for a penny each on Amazon.

There’s a problem with this binge reading though. Sure, it’s intensely pleasurable, and you really end up inhabiting the author’s world – in Barbara Pym’s case the ebbs and flows of parish life and the vanities of the clergy, or in Anne Tyler’s the subterranean tensions and longings in middle-aged relationships – but after a while I start not to be able to distinguish the novels from one another. All that remains of my minor Tyler obsession a decade ago is a tangled sense of blended families in Baltimore. At this distance, only Breathing Lessons now stands out as something distinctive.

So I ought to do the sensible thing and take a break between Barbara Pym novels. This punch-drunk feeling is not helped by the fact that all the jacket covers look so damn similar and frankly a bit chick-lit-y, which rather does her writing a disservice (see picture). I think I might be more reliant on visual triggers than I thought; certainly, it’s much harder to recall what I’ve read if I’ve consumed it on the Kindle, which is one of the reasons I’ve returned to the enjoyment of print again. Thank God for Penguin Classics covers. I have strong physical recollections of where I was when I read Ann Veronica and the War of the Worlds, to take a random example, and that in turn allows me to call to mind both plot and texture.  Reading on a screen flattens out the fading memory.



Filed under Books, Fiction

3 responses to “The perils and pleasures of binge reading

  1. Ha like you, my love affair with the Kindle is well and truly over …..quite useful when travelling ( esp on budget airline flights) but otherwise I have returned to print.
    I am also a natural binge reader too ….do you think it’s part of the box-ticking , cover-all-bases nature of a lawyer’s mind ( I’m one too). I do try to break up the binging with something else in between each one otherwise you are right, you’re just left with an overall impression rather than enjoying each one for what it is !
    Currently on an Elizabeth Jane Howard jag btw ;))

  2. Totally agree. I took a Kindle on holiday in the summer and that was fine, but it is worse than useless for a cosy bedtime read. I stare at too many screens all day for it to be physically comfortable late at night. Also, I speed-read far too much on a Kindle – it feels like I’m scanning the latest headline rather than becoming immersed in the text.

  3. I’ve also gone back to print- I use Kindle on ipad for holidays only but nothing beats a real book. I used to love Anne Tyler. I once got left a manuscript of her novel on my doorstep by Nick Hornby. But that’s a whole other story.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s